Penn State: Do the Right Thing

Sean Clark

April 20, 2006

Recently, Penn State University sent out a discussing an event called “Illegal Immigration Awareness Day” being planned by the College Republicans. Although provocative, the event itself is not the interesting part. What is notable are the comments made by the administration concerning the students’ right to hold the event.

Terrell Jones, Vice Provost for Educational Equity, stated:

The College Republicans certainly have a Constitutional right to conduct such an event, offensive as it may appear to some in the community. In protecting everyone's right to free expression, the University cannot censor the content of student-organized events. (emphasis added)

Then, Penn State President Graham Spanier remarked:

The nation's immigration policy is a legitimate topic for discussion and debate, and a university is clearly an ideal forum for such discourse. We encourage discussion on such issues…However, the approach initially proposed by the College Republicans, while protected by the First Amendment, was unproductive and offensive to many. (emphasis added)

The press release concludes by stating:

While promoting free speech and expression, the University takes this opportunity to reiterate its clearly stated policy prohibiting acts of discrimination against any person because of age, ancestry, color, disability or handicap, national origin, race, religious creed, sex, sexual orientation or veteran status. While not applicable to free speech and expression, the University will continue to enforce this policy… . (emphasis added)

As far as university administrators go, these statements are a pretty good. But, if Penn State is such a bastion of liberty, why is it a “red light” school that was recently sued for its unconstitutional speech codes?

If President Spanier believes what he is saying, instead of , he should immediately do away with them.

Recent Articles

FIRE’s award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed.

Trump's $16M win over '60 Minutes' edit sends chilling message to journalists everywhere

July 2, 2025

Trump's $16M win over a "60 Minutes" edit sends a chilling message to journalists everywhere. ��ýapp�ٷ�’s Bob Corn-Revere calls it what it is: the FCC playing politics.

To speak or not to speak: Universities face the Kalven question

July 1, 2025

As political pressure mounts, Dinah Megibow-Taylor explores whether recent institutional statements defend academic freedom — or quietly erode it.

Dark forbidding troubled storm sky over the Supreme Court building in Washington

FIREstatement on Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton upholding age verification for adult content

June 27, 2025

Today, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to uphold Texas's age-verification law for sites featuring adult content, effectively reversing decades of Supreme Court precedent that protects the free speech rights of adults to access information without jumping over government age-verification hurdles.

Rebecca Bryant Novak conducting an orchestra

Orchestrated silence: How one of America’s most elite music schools expelled a student for reporting harassment

June 26, 2025

Rebecca Bryant Novak earned her spot at one of the world’s top music schools. But after reporting her advisor for harassment, she says the school turned on her. Now FIREis demanding answers.

��ýapp�ٷ�

Table of Contents